No one told you your traditional retirement money still has taxes attached.
Traditional IRA and 401(k) money usually went in before income taxes were paid.
When taxable money comes back out, it generally counts as ordinary income.
Most of us were taught one retirement rule:
Put money in the 401(k).
Nobody spent much time explaining what happens when it is time to take the money back out.
That is where taxes, Roth conversions, early-withdrawal rules and RMDs suddenly show up.
Traditional IRA and 401(k) money usually went in before income taxes were paid.
When taxable money comes back out, it generally counts as ordinary income.
With traditional retirement money, you usually get the tax break first and pay tax later.
With Roth money, you pay tax first and qualified withdrawals later are tax-free.
That is called a Roth conversion.
You choose to pay the tax on the converted amount now so that qualified withdrawals from the Roth later can be tax-free.
You can convert part of it.
Because conversions create taxable income, spreading them over several years can avoid creating one enormous tax year.
Your paycheck may disappear before Social Security and required withdrawals begin.
That can create lower-income years when you control how much traditional retirement money you choose to convert.
A Roth conversion adds taxable income.
A very large conversion can push some income into higher tax brackets and may increase other income-based costs.
If tax withholding comes out of the retirement account itself, less money reaches the Roth.
If you have enough cash elsewhere to cover the tax, more of the converted retirement money stays invested.
Traditional retirement withdrawals generally count as taxable income.
States tax that income differently.
For most Gen Xers born in 1960 or later, current law starts these required withdrawals at age 75.
RMD means Required Minimum Distribution.
It is the minimum amount tax rules require you to withdraw from certain retirement accounts each year once the rules apply to you.
If you need the money to live on, an RMD is simply retirement savings turning into retirement income.
The downside is loss of control. You may have taxable income even in a year when you would rather leave the money invested.
If you leave a job during or after the calendar year you turn 55, withdrawals from that employer's qualified plan may qualify for the Rule of 55 exception.
Regular income tax may still apply.
The Rule of 55 exception applies to qualifying employer plans, not IRAs.
That makes automatic rollover timing worth understanding before you move the account.
Those extra contributions are called catch-up contributions.
Under current rules, workers in those ages may qualify for a larger catch-up limit than the normal age-50+ amount.
Many non-spouse beneficiaries must empty an inherited retirement account within 10 years.
Traditional IRA withdrawals are generally taxable to the heir.
Taking money from an IRA before 59½ does not automatically mean every dollar is hit with the 10% additional early-distribution tax. Traditional and Roth IRAs follow different rules, and federal law includes exceptions. The important question is not simply, “Am I under 59½?” It is, “What kind of IRA money is this, and does an exception apply?”
A Roth conversion does not happen by itself. The amount you convert becomes part of that year’s tax picture, alongside everything else that happened. The same conversion can have a very different result in a quiet income year than it does in a year with wages, investment gains, Social Security, a taxable home-sale gain or other income. That is why “Should I do a Roth conversion?” is incomplete. The better question is: “What else is happening this year if I do it?”
A Roth conversion creates a tax bill, but that does not tell you where the money to pay the tax should come from. Cash, taxable investments and IRA money can all be possible sources. Each choice gives something up. The best source depends on what you actually own, the tax created by using that source and what you need the remaining money to do.
Traditional 401(k) money usually gave you a tax break while you were working. You generally pay income tax when you take that money out in retirement. That means the amount you withdraw in a given year matters. Taking a very large amount all at once can push some of your income into higher tax brackets than spreading withdrawals over several years. Qualified Roth 401(k) withdrawals work differently and can be tax-free.
A Roth account is a retirement account funded with money that has already been taxed. You paid taxes on that money before you put it in your Roth account. As a result, the money inside the Roth can keep growing tax-free. That means, if you meet the withdrawal requirements, you can cash-out the money in your Roth tax-free. That's why you hear so much about Roth IRAs. The money in it grows tax-free. A Roth conversion means moving money from a traditional IRA or other pre-tax retirement account into a Roth account. Since that traditional money was not taxed when you put it in, the amount you convert generally becomes taxable income when you remove it from your traditional IRA to put it into a Roth. The tradeoff is that the converted money can then grow inside the Roth, and future withdrawals can be tax-free once the Roth rules are met. You do not have to convert the whole account. You can convert only part of it. Why would you want to convert only part of it at a time? So you can keep the taxes you pay at the time of conversion lower than if you converted the entire amount at once. Ugh. This is getting complicated. Stick with it. All will be explained below.
After decades of being told not to touch your retirement savings, the rule eventually flips. The government requires you to start taking a minimum amount out of many pre-tax retirement accounts every year. Why? Because the government let you postpone paying income tax on that money while you were saving it. It eventually wants to collect the tax. Those forced minimum withdrawals are called Required Minimum Distributions, or RMDs. Under current law, most Gen Xers born in 1960 or later have to start RMDs at age 75.